Pops Change Exchange

Collector guide & live listings

Buffalo Nickels for Sale

Browse Buffalo nickels with live inventory, clear photographs, and simple filters for date, grade, price, and certification.

1936-S 5C Buffalo Nickel (VF+) obverse

Buffalo nickels are a hands-on series: dates often wear away, and a strong strike can matter as much as the grade. Check the date, mint mark, and the buffalo’s leg before buying.

Key dates, semi-keys & varieties

Date / varietyMintagePlain-language note
1913-S Type 21,209,000A key regular issue.
1921-S1,557,000Scarcer San Francisco issue.
1926-S970,000Low mintage; often weakly struck.
1937-D 3 LegsUnknownA famous die variety, not a separate regular mintage.

Historical reference: PCGS / U.S. Mint reference. Mintages are original production totals, not survival counts.

Buffalo Nickels for Sale

48 coins found

Showing 41–48

CompareCoinSeriesPriceActions
1936-S 5C Buffalo Nickel (VF+) obverse1936-S 5C Buffalo Nickel (VF+)
Buffalo Nickels$26
1937 5C Buffalo Nickel (AU) obverse1937 5C Buffalo Nickel (AU)
Buffalo Nickels$30
1937 5C Buffalo Nickel (VF+) obverse1937 5C Buffalo Nickel (VF+)
Buffalo NickelsAuction listing; no fixed price
1937 Buffalo Nickel • Philadelphia Mint • VF Original Circulated Buffalo — obverse1937 Buffalo Nickel • Philadelphia Mint • VF Original Circulated Buffalo
Buffalo Nickels$3.50
1937-D 5C Buffalo Nickel (F+) obverse1937-D 5C Buffalo Nickel (F+)
Buffalo NickelsAuction listing; no fixed price
1937-D 5C Buffalo Nickel (XF) obverse1937-D 5C Buffalo Nickel (XF)
Buffalo NickelsAuction listing; no fixed price
1937-D Buffalo Nickel • Denver Mint • AU Collector Buffalo Nickel — obverse1937-D Buffalo Nickel • Denver Mint • AU Collector Buffalo Nickel
Buffalo Nickels$3.50
1937-S 5C Buffalo Nickel (F+) obverse1937-S 5C Buffalo Nickel (F+)
Buffalo NickelsAuction listing; no fixed price

Side-by-side review

Compare your selected coins

Choose up to four coins from the result tables. Closing this window keeps your comparison in this browser tab.